Print this article

Earning Investors’ Trust: What Firms Must Do - CFA

Jackie Bennion

6 May 2020

The CFA Institute has released a timely report on trust in the industry, just as clients are forensically examining how reassuring, competent and indeed accessible their investment managers have been the last few months when fear and panic have been doing their upmost to derail sound investment decision-making.

The global finance body surveyed more than 4,000 retail and institutional investors across 15 markets in 2019 for its fourth edition on trust – including 550 UK investors, where results showed that confidence was noticeably below the global average.

Trust levels among UK investors dropped from 46 per cent to 33 per cent in the lastest report. Confidence in their advisors' ability to manage through a crisis also scored lower among UK investors, down from 50 to 42 per cent in the last year, against a global average of 49 per cent.

The report titled Earning Investors’ Trust: How the Desire for Information, Innovation, and Influence is Shaping Client Relationship, analyzed trust dimensions at the system, industry and firm level. The report calls trust "a multi-layered concept" dependent on information , innovation , and influence .

The poll consistently found that investors want more information, innovation, and influence in their interactions with the industry. Roll to the pandemic and “This time of heightened market volatility sets up a very different path for those who will succeed in meeting their investment goals and those who will not,” Margaret Franklin president and CEO of CFA Institute said.

Indians trust, Australians not so
The survey included retail investors aged 25 or older with at least US$100,000 to invest, and institutional investors and HNWs managing at least US$50 million. Across the 15 markets, the report found that Indian retail investors displayed the highest trust levels in their financial services sector, while Australia scored the lowest at 24 per cent. Comparisons from 2018 to 2020, saw trust rise most in Hong Kong, India, the UAE, and Brazil, and fall most in Singapore and Australia.

What to do, then?
With credibility and professionalism seen as the leading factors for building trust, the institute recommends eight steps that organizations can take to build trust:
* Maintain strong brand identity and follow through on brand promises
* Employ professionals with credentials from respected industry organizations
* Stay focused on building a long-term track record to demonstrate competence
* Adopt relevant industry codes to reinforce your firm’s commitment to ethics and make your performance results comparable across securities, asset classes, and clients
* Professionalism: improve transparency and clarity regarding fees, security, and conflicts of interest
* Use clear language to demonstrate that client interests come first
* Showcase your ongoing professional development to improve investment knowledge.
*Demonstrate your dedication to the values that clients hold dear.

Tech versus human
While only 13 per cent of retail investors and 16 per cent of institutional investors said they would consider leaving their investment firm because of insufficient technology, when forced to choose between tech tools and human access, tech tools are beginning to win out. For the first time, retail investors in aggregate showed an equal preference for technology as people.


 

There is no disputing the value of technology. But the picture is nuanced. The increased appetite for tech is entirely among the 25–34 age group, while other generations are showing less appetite or just maintaining the status quo.

Since 2018, the CFA found that the preference for technology has dropped in six of the 15 markets, including the US, Brazil, France, Singapore, mainland China, and Hong Kong. Still there is growing interest in more customized products, where nearly half of all retail investors—especially younger ones— said they would pay more for customization.

Trust and returns
Among institutional investors, returns have become even more important in hiring an investment firm than having someone trusted to act in their best interest. Low interest rates have piled pressure on return expectations, particularly for pension funds.

But it is different for retail investors, who still "prioritize having someone trusted to act in their best interest and a recommendation from someone they trust when looking to hire an advisor, with an assumption that returns will follow," the report said, adding the caveat that managers took the survey while still in a bull market.

 

Persistent self interest
Few across institutional and retail believed that firms put clients’ interests before their own , in spite of the fact that 75 per cent of retail investors believed that their advisor is legally bound to act for them before themselves.  Also, in spite of a steady stream of new tools connecting clients with advisors, perceptions around transparency are not improving.

Role of fees
Retail and institutional investors agreed that one of the most important factors for creating trust is full fees and costs disclosures, but there was little confidence in those conversations becoming more open. That said, around three-quarters believe that the fees they pay are fair, even as the survey showed that high fees are one of the main reasons that investors give for leaving a firm. Not just disclosing but explaining fees and costs is an important way of building trust and hanging on to clients in these difficult markets.

Rise of brands
Brand was increasingly mentioned as a marker of trust, especially among younger investors. Three quarters of younger investors said they would rather work with a firm with “a brand I can trust” than one with “people I can count on.”

Roughly half of retail investors without an advisor thought they had a fair chance of profiting from capital market investments, compared with 81 per cent for those with an advisor, suggesting that there is a market to win over.

The CFA underscores that everyone is scrambling to “adapt” but "those with a trusted relationship are much better equipped to navigate disruption.”

Not surprisingly, institutional investors were the most keen on investing in funds that use artificial intelligence, and nearly half of early adopters were interested in investing in products created by a big tech firm such as Amazon, Google, or Alibaba over those produced by a financial institution.

ESG is also rising in priorities, with over two-thirds in both camps expressing an interest. Two-thirds of institutional investors believe that the growth of ESG investing has increased trust in financial services as a whole.